|
ALM First Financial Advisors
Economic Overview
Prepared
by: Angela Calvert
Fourth Quarter 2000
TOPICS
COVERED
Introduction
Let
me begin by saying that writing this commentary has proved
to be quite a difficult task. In the years past, explaining
and predicting changes in the market seemed a much easier
feat than it does today. Mr. Greenspan said it best when he
made reference to the underlying performance of the US economy
by calling it "an environment with so little historical precedence."
In spite of that, the term "New Economy" had begun to seem
over used and sort of like a cliché. But as each day unfolds,
this term is proving to be more accurate. Who needs Disney
World when you live day to day in a market with more unexpected
ups and downs than Space Mountain? After the presidential
race/marathon (don't even get me started on that!), we all
thought it was time to take a breather. After all, which one
of us didn't blame a lot of the strange and unusual twists
in the equities and fixed income markets at least partially
on the election. Out of the frying pan and into the fire,
as they say!
Let us jump right in by summing up some of the major changes
that have occurred just over the last twelve months:
-
The
Fed Funds Rate increased by 100 basis points.
-
The
FOMC's economic assessment had moved from neutral to inflationary
to economic weakness.
-
The
worries of inflation have moved onto worries of a recession.A
new President, along with a new political party is on its
way into office.
Past
Quarters
In December of 1999, there was a Fed Funds rate of 5.50% with
a neutral economic bias from the FOMC. The tightening mode
began in February 2000 with a 25 basis point increase. By
mid year, the economy remained robust but inflation seemed
contained. Throughout the course of 2000, we would see funds
continue upward to 6.50%.
Looking
at the yield curve, from the beginning of September 2000 investors
had begun to sit on the sidelines. The two-year slipped below
6% as more and more money poured into the fixed income market
from an out of control stock market. Nearing the end of the
third quarter came the first signs that things were really
about to change. During this time, all eyes and concerns were
zeroing in on inflation. It seemed nothing but bad news and
poor earnings could come out of an already volatile equity
market. From there, bond prices soared as yields continued
to plummet. From third quarter to year-end, the yield on the
two-year Treasury yield dropped like a rock. As bond buyers
held their breath and waited for the hopeful "correction",
it never came. But no one, if we are all honest, saw the next
event coming. (Well, at least not from a timing perspective!)
In mid-day trading on January 3, 2001, at an unscheduled meeting,
the Fed lowered rates 50 basis points.
The two-year
that had been flirting with a 5% handle in December, has now
dated it, married it, divorced it, and moved on to the 4%
handle! The yield on the two-year Treasury Note dropped from
the 5.90% range at the end of October 2000 to 5.10% at year-end.
By mid January, the yield had dropped another 22 basis points
to 4.88%. The long end of the curve, which is no longer inverted,
has returned to its more "normal" shape. The ten-year moved
from 5.04% in December to 5.24% just 14 days into the New
Year. That flat curve that many investors were complaining
about suddenly doesn't sound so bad to a short-term investor.
Growth,
or is it the Lack of?'
One big
concern in the market place is that all of the Federal Reserves
hard work may have paid off too much. Over the past quarter,
the goal was to keep the economy's expansion, which is in
its record 10th year, steady while keeping inflation in check.
Around November, as the economy began to show signs of slowing,
the concern shifted that it may be slowing too much. With
a revised, third-quarter, real GDP falling to 2.2%, the suddenness
and degree of reported weakness was startling. The leading
indicators suggest a fourth quarter continued downward trend
with an expected GDP of 1.5%. With November and December weather
being the coldest

since
1895, the problem may be exaggerated somewhat, but the extent
of new layoffs and corporate credit problems argue that the
potential for real trouble is brewing. The risk of outright
recession has now moved to 50% and a hard landing is not out
of the question. For 2001 as a whole, real GDP is expected
to be 2.0% or lower on a calendar average basis.
Inflation:
Active or Dormant?
The hot
topic last year was the ever-soaring price of oil. OPEC took
us on a roller coaster ride from promising increases in oil
production to not promising enough. Oil hit an all time high
in November, as many of us have felt from our heating bills.
By December the price had dropped again, but that joy was
short lived. Crude oil soared almost 7% the first week into
2001, after colder-than-normal weather
reduced
US heating oil supplies. Inventories of the fuel fell 4.60%,
leaving them 19% lower than one year ago. Crude oil for February
delivery rose $1.84, or 67%, to $29.48 a barrel. Prices have
risen in January by 10% after dropping 21% during December.
Another inflationary indicator is gold.
Contrary
to oil, the price of gold has continued to decline since September
of 1999, minus a few spikes here and there. While December's
PPI rate was unchanged, its core rate, which excludes
food and
energy, rose an unexpected 0.3%. The Consumer Price Index
has remained fairly docile except for the small spike in September,
and is expected to remain unchanged in December at 0.2%.
More
Bad News
In the
first week of the new year, the monthly Purchasing Managers'
survey, which Greenspan has often cited as one of the most
reliable indicators of manufacturing activity, showed a sharp
plunge in December to 43.7 from 47.7 - a level not seen since
the recession of 1990-91. Also that week, auto sales were
reported and fell off the proverbial cliff. The auto industry
is one area that impacts a lot of segments of many different
industries. Demand for everything from electronic components
to textiles to leather and leather products to petroleum is
influenced by the ebb and flow in the auto industry. Following
a two-year boom that hoisted annual auto sales to more than
17 million units annually, sales came back to earth, leaving
auto inventories at their highest level relative to sales
since 1996. In turn, the slowdown in auto loans will surely
continue.
Employment
Concerns
With recent
layoffs and the downward trend of manufacturing, the needle
naturally falls toward unemployment. The December
employment
numbers, coupled with the weakness in the factory sector,
are the primary reasons the Fed cut interest rates so quickly.
In December, Non-Farm Payrolls rose by 105,000 and the US
unemployment rate held constant at 4%. Put another way,
the number
of people entering the labor force in December matched the
number of people who found employment. The interesting twist
was that businesses added the fewest workers in four months.
Companies created 49,000 jobs last month, after adding 111,000
in November, the Labor Department said. Also noted was a gain
in wages last month as average hourly earning rose 0.4%, after
a 0.6% in November. It is important to remember that the unemployment
rate is a lagging indicator and may take a few months to respond
to the recent layoffs.
Consumer
Concerns
Although
retail sales showed that Santa did still make his rounds this
year, a 0.1% increase makes us believe that maybe either his
elves didn't work as hard during the year or there weren't
enough good boys and girls to justify a lot of presents! This
number also shows weakness in key sectors such as General
Merchandise (chain stores) at -0.5% and "Eating and Drinking"
places fell 0.4%.
Another
key issue to keep an eye on is Consumer Confidence, which
has been taking a hit since midyear. With 44% of banks tightening
credit and a stock market more volatile than a volcano, the
consumer has reason to sway from its recent enthusiasm.
Consumer
Credit continues to give support to the theory that the shopper
might be a little down, but by no means out.
Which
is the drug of choice?
With the
economy in an obvious slowdown and the remedy appears to be
some sort of a boost to the consumer, which is the more appropriate
medicine, a tax cut or a rate cut? Some speculate that the
unexpected interest-rate cut during the first week of 2001
was Alan's way of telling George W. "Hands Off! I have things
under control!" Whether there was a hidden meaning or not,
President-elect George W. Bush's advisers are now facing their
first big economic policy challenge - how to speed up the
tax cuts he has proposed without creating friction with the
Federal Reserve. If Bush was to stick with the original plan,
$1.3 trillion over 10 years,
next one!
The
Forecast
Although the economy appears to be slowing rather rapidly,
the Fed has taken quick and immediate steps to intervene.
During the first quarter of 2001, we expect another 25-50
basis point ease from the FOMC, followed by another 25-50
by midyear. The two-year Treasury should trade between 4.30%
and 4.65% through the 1st Quarter of 2001.
|